Skip to main content

KQ Law, PLLC

Personal Guarantees on Leases: What Tenants and Guarantors Need to Know | KQ Law, PLLC

What Is a Personal Guaranty?

Suppose you own a restaurant called Bob’s Burgers, LLC. The lease will typically name the property owner as the landlord and Bob’s Burgers, LLC as the tenant. Oftentimes, for new businesses, landlords will also ask the business owner to sign an individual personal guaranty, which is typically an agreement attached to the commercial lease and signed at the same time. The person guaranteeing the lease is known as the guarantor.

Generally speaking, by signing the personal guaranty, you are effectively agreeing that if the business fails to meet its obligations under the lease, you will be personally responsible for those obligations. If the business defaults under the lease, such as by failing to pay rent, the landlord has the right to sue not only the business itself but you personally as the guarantor of the lease.

Consider this example: Your business goes under during the third year of a five-year lease, and you personally guaranteed the entire term of the lease. Depending on the terms of the lease and guaranty, the landlord may have the right to seek damages for rent and other amounts that become due after the business defaults, such as rent that would have become due for the remainder of the lease.

For example, if the monthly rent is $5,000 and 24 months remain on the lease, the remaining base rent alone would total $120,000. Additional charges, such as operating expenses, late fees, attorneys’ fees, or other amounts permitted under the lease, could increase your liability.

Personal Liability for Lease Debt

When a business is struggling or goes out of business and has few or no remaining assets, the landlord may recognize that there is little to recover from the business itself. The landlord may still obtain a judgment against the business for the amounts owed, but if the business has no meaningful assets, that judgment may have limited practical value. In many cases, the judgment against the individual guarantor is where the landlord may have a meaningful opportunity to recover the money owed, because the guarantor may have personal assets, such as real estate, that can potentially be reached to satisfy the judgment.

Depending on how your property is titled, a judgment against you individually may also create a lien or otherwise give the creditor rights against real estate that you own. In some circumstances, this can potentially allow a creditor to pursue the sale of property to satisfy the judgment. Whether a property can be reached, and whether a forced sale is possible, can depend on factors such as how the property is titled, whether it is jointly owned, applicable homestead or other exemptions, the amount of equity in the property, and the law of the state where the property is located.

This is one of the most important risks to understand before signing a personal guaranty. A business owner may believe that the worst-case scenario is losing the business. But when a lease is personally guaranteed, the financial consequences of a business default can potentially extend beyond the business itself and affect the owner’s personal assets.

I have seen business owners who did not fully understand the extent of the personal guaranty they signed later face lawsuits like the above example. Depending on the terms of the lease and guaranty, what began as a business debt can potentially become a personal financial liability of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Understand the Scope of the Personal Guaranty

The extent of that personal liability depends on the language of the guaranty. Some guaranties are limited. For example, a guaranty may make the owner responsible for only a certain percentage of the outstanding debt or may expire after a specified number of years. Other guaranties can be much broader and may make the guarantor responsible for all or substantially all of the tenant’s obligations under the lease.

The terms of the lease and the guaranty should therefore be reviewed together. Provisions addressing rent, additional charges, default, attorneys’ fees, damages, and the duration or scope of the guaranty can all affect the amount a landlord may seek from a guarantor.

A guaranty’s wording may not settle every question about whether it can be enforced. People make drafting mistakes, misunderstand the law, or use language that does not clearly express what they intended. In some cases, there may also be questions about how the guaranty was executed, whether it was properly incorporated into the lease, or whether subsequent changes to the lease affected the guarantor’s obligations. Those issues can affect what a landlord can recover and what a tenant or guarantor is ultimately responsible for.

For that reason, you should not assume that simply because you signed a personal guaranty, you automatically owe every amount the landlord claims. The specific language of the guaranty, the underlying lease, the circumstances surrounding the default, and applicable law can all matter. If a landlord is demanding payment or has filed a lawsuit, reviewing the lease and guaranty carefully can help determine the extent of your potential liability and whether there are defenses or other issues that may affect the claim.

Always Check What Happens to the Guaranty When You Sell the Business

The issue can become particularly important when the business is sold. As part of the sale, the buyer may assume the lease and take over the tenant’s obligations. But what happens if the new owner later stops paying rent?

Depending on the agreements signed during the sale, the original owner’s personal guaranty may remain in place even after the business has been sold. In that situation, the seller could remain personally responsible for a lease that is now controlled by someone else. If the business is later sold, the seller should confirm in writing whether the existing personal guaranty will end. Ideally, the new owner should sign a new guaranty so there is no confusion about who remains responsible under the lease.

Have Your Personal Guaranty Reviewed

It is common for landlords to require a business owner to personally guarantee a commercial lease. Before signing, however, both sides should have an attorney review the terms and make sure they understand their obligations. A personal guaranty can expose a business owner to significant personal liability. Understanding exactly what you are agreeing to before you sign can help you avoid problems later.

If you have questions about a personal guaranty or your obligations under a business lease, reach out for a consultation to discuss your situation.

Disclaimer: Every case is different. The information provided is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. You should speak with a qualified attorney about the specific facts of your situation to determine your rights and legal options.

Call: (703) 906-4782